I'm not usually a nervous person, I swear

But I can't speak to you without rehearsing in the mirror

Spilling feelings and making moves feel like

Classic butterflies if you set them all on fire

Every day with you

I learn something new

Thought I knew was love was

Thought I'd been through enough

But since you've been holding my heart

I've been sprinting in the dark

You're in a league of your own

And no love has ever come close

It's not my first time, but it might as well be

You make me feel, you make me feel like a rookie

You make me feel like a rookie

Under the stars in Jersey half-asleep

You said the sky looked like a shiny ceiling

There's nothing about you that I don't want more of

There's a lot about me, I'm afraid won't measure up

Thought I knew was love was

Thought I'd been through enough

But since you've been holding my heart

I've been sprinting in the dark

You're in a league of your own

No love has ever come close

It's not my first time, but it might as well be

You make me feel, you make me feel like a rookie

You make me feel like a rookie

Thought I knew was love was

Thought I'd been through enough

But since you've been holding my heart

I've been sprinting in the dark

You're in a league of your own (oh-oh)

And no love has ever come close (no)

It's not my first time, but it might as well be

You make me feel, you make me feel like a rookie

You make me feel like a rookie

If you're the one that I'm doing (no)

You make me feel like a rookie

It's not my first time, but it might as well be

You make me feel, you make me feel like a rookie