You haven't changed a bit

Except for that new tattoo

You left one on me too

You've got some nerve, you do

Making me this nervous

Got me leaning on this Long Island courage

This beach is where we met

Same place we said goodbye

You're the x that marks the spot

Where part of me still lies

Time buried all the treasure we had

I'm interested in stealing it back

All the golden days, we'll find them

Dig up every dirt road diamond

We left on this small town island like

We're pirates tonight

(Just like pirates tonight, just like)

(Just like pirates tonight)

Let's take a drive through town

Without teenage intentions

Red light kisses with no curfew to end them

Let's rob that rearview blind

If we don't, it'd be a crime

You're the ex that marks the spot

Where part of me still lies

Time buried all the treasure we had (treasure we had)

I'm interested in stealing it back (stealing it back)

All the golden days, we'll find 'em

Dig up every dirt road diamond

We left on this small town island like

We're pirates tonight

(Just like pirates tonight, just like)

(Just like pirates tonight)

Let's chase every dead end on memory lane

Replace all those lost footprints the waves washed away

Time buried all the treasure we had (treasure we had)

I'm interested in stealing it back (stealing it back)

All the golden days, we'll find 'em

Dig up every dirt road diamond

We left on this small town island like

We're pirates tonight

Time buried all the treasure we had

(Just like pirates tonight)

I'm interested in stealing it back

(Just like pirates tonight)